Chapter 2 - WHAT CHLOE SAW ON SUNDAY
We did not call Marcus.
We did not respond to his message.
Instead, I took screenshots and forwarded everything to a new email account.
Liam watched from across the kitchen.
“What are you doing?”
“Preserving evidence.”
“He’ll know.”
“He already knows Chloe exposed him.”
“You don’t understand how dangerous he is.”
“Then help me understand.”
Liam finally told me everything.
The blackmail began six months after the accident.
Marcus visited Liam’s apartment carrying an audio recorder.
He played a conversation from the hospital parking lot.
Liam sounded disoriented.
He repeatedly said he had killed Evan.
Marcus asked leading questions.
“Why were you driving after drinking?”
“How could you let Evan sit beside you?”
“What will your parents do when they learn you killed their youngest son?”
Liam never clearly admitted driving.
But edited properly, the recording sounded devastating.
Marcus promised to destroy it if Liam paid for a new business venture.
Liam gave him ten thousand dollars.
The demands continued.
A vehicle.
A loan.
Construction materials.
Cash.
Subcontracts awarded to companies Marcus secretly owned.
Whenever Liam resisted, Marcus sent part of the recording.
At our wedding, Marcus stood beside Liam as best man with the flash drive in his pocket.
The thought made me physically ill.
“He gave a speech about loyalty,” I said.
Liam stared at the table.
“I know.”
“When I was pregnant?”
“He demanded twenty-five thousand dollars.”
“You told me a client refused to pay.”
“Yes.”
“After Chloe was born?”
“He said fatherhood made me vulnerable.”
Every happy memory now contained Marcus standing just outside the frame.
“What happened three Sundays ago?”
“Marcus demanded fifty thousand dollars.”
“For what?”
“He said he had gambling debts.”
“And you gave it to him?”
“Only fifteen. I told him I couldn’t get more.”
“That is why you were crying.”
Liam nodded.
“He said he would send the recording to you and my parents. Then Chloe started knocking on the shed door.”
“What did Marcus do?”
“He smiled and told me children remember nothing.”
Chloe remembered everything.
I called my sister and asked her to keep Chloe overnight.
Then I contacted Detective Rachel Sloan.
Rachel had been my college roommate before joining the state police. We had not spoken regularly in years, but I trusted her.
I gave her the messages without telling Liam first.
When he learned, he became furious.
“You called the police?”
“I called someone who can tell us what options exist.”
“You had no right.”
“I am your wife, Liam. Marcus threatened our family.”
“This is my problem.”
“No. Your secrecy made it mine.”
He paced the living room.
For a moment, I saw how fear had shaped him.
Marcus had trained Liam to believe every attempt at help would trigger disaster.
“Rachel is coming here,” I said.
“When?”
“Tonight.”
“I won’t speak to her.”
“You don’t have to. But I will.”
Rachel arrived at nine wearing jeans and a raincoat.
She listened without interrupting.
Then she asked Liam for the exact location of the accident.
He gave it reluctantly.
“Were blood samples collected?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“From all occupants?”
“I don’t know.”
“Was Marcus treated at the scene?”
“He disappeared.”
“That would have been noted.”
“Not if police never knew he was there.”
Rachel opened an old case database through her department-issued laptop.
The accident report listed two occupants.
Evan in the driver’s seat.
Liam in the rear passenger seat.
No third person.
But a supplemental paramedic note described a blood trail leading from the front passenger door into nearby grass.
Police assumed it belonged to Liam after he crawled from the vehicle.
Liam had been unconscious when responders arrived.
“That blood may belong to Marcus,” Rachel said.
“Would a sample still exist?” I asked.
“Possibly. Some evidence from fatal crashes is preserved longer than standard cases.”
Liam looked up for the first time.
Rachel continued.
“The vehicle may also have been stored rather than destroyed if insurance litigation occurred.”
“My parents never sued,” Liam said.
“The manufacturer conducted a safety review because an airbag failed.”
A chance existed that the car—or parts of it—remained in evidence storage.
“We need the drive,” Rachel said. “But we also need independent proof. If Marcus releases the recording before we establish context, public opinion could be ugly.”
Liam gave a humorless laugh.
“That’s what he wants.”
Rachel studied him.
“Why do you believe his witness?”
“He once sent me a photograph of a woman near the crash site. He said she saw me driving.”
“Did you recognize her?”
“No.”
“Could she have seen the car before Marcus took over?”
Liam froze.
He had been driving earlier.
A witness might honestly remember him behind the wheel without seeing the later switch.
Marcus had built his threat from fragments of truth.
Rachel advised us not to confront him.
She requested the archived crash file and began preparing an extortion investigation.
Then Chloe returned home the next morning and added another detail.
She was eating cereal when she said:
“Marcus’s boot sings.”
I sat beside her.
“What does it sound like?”
She hummed three electronic tones.
Liam recognized them.
“The drive is encrypted. It makes a sound when connected to Marcus’s phone.”
“Did you see his phone?”
Chloe nodded.
“He puts the tiny black thing in the white cord. Then Daddy talks from inside.”
Marcus had played the recording in front of her.
“What else was on the phone?” Rachel asked gently.
Chloe thought carefully.
“A red car.”
The accident vehicle had been red.
“And a lady with yellow hair.”
The mysterious witness.
“Was she talking?”
“Yes. She said Daddy was not driving.”
Every adult in the room went still.
Marcus’s witness did not accuse Liam.
She cleared him.
“Are you sure, sweetheart?” I asked.
Chloe nodded.
“She said, ‘The other boy had the wheel.’ Then Marcus got mad and closed it.”
Marcus possessed a video statement proving Liam was not driving.
He had lied about its contents for years.
“Did you see the lady’s name?” Rachel asked.
Chloe could not read well enough.
But she remembered a picture beside the video.
“A flower.”
“What kind?”
“Yellow, like the sun.”
A sunflower.
It might have been a profile image.
Rachel searched the original accident report for nearby witnesses.
One caller was listed only by first name:
Daisy.
A flower.
Daisy Moore had called 911 from a farmhouse near the crash.
Police never interviewed her because dispatch notes said she had not witnessed the impact.
Marcus may have found her later.
If Daisy told him she saw someone else driving, he buried the statement.
Rachel located an address in rural Wisconsin.
Daisy Moore still lived there.
By afternoon, we were driving toward her farm.
Liam sat silently beside me.
“What if she refuses to speak?” he asked.
“Then we ask once.”
“And if she says she saw me?”
“Then we deal with the truth.”
He looked at me.
“How can you be so calm?”
“I’m not calm.”
I placed my hand over his.
“I’m done allowing fear to make decisions before facts arrive.”
Daisy opened the farmhouse door holding a wooden cane.
She was sixty-seven, with pale hair and clear blue eyes.
The moment she saw Liam, recognition crossed her face.
“You’re the boy from the red car.”
Liam swallowed.
“Yes.”
Her next words changed the case.
May you like
“I’ve been waiting seven years for someone to ask the right question.”
---
