Chapter 4 - The Professor’s Secret Research
I did not want to believe Noah had helped attack Lily.
Her notes told her to ask him for help.
His message warned her not to meet anyone alone.
Yet Lily had identified him as being present.
Detective Quinn carefully clarified the question.
“Was Noah there when you were hurt?”
YES.
“Did Noah strike you?”
NO.
“Did he try to help?”
Lily’s hand hovered.
Then pressed YES.
“Did he leave you?”
Tears rolled down her face.
YES.
Noah had witnessed the attack.
He may have tried to stop it.
Then he disappeared.
The police issued an alert, but Noah had withdrawn cash and abandoned his car near a bus station.
Someone was helping him flee—or someone was hunting him.
We needed to understand the research.
Professor Monroe arranged for an independent scientist, Dr. Priya Shah, to review Lily’s sample bottles and copied data.
Dr. Shah worked at a different university and had no connection to Halcyon.
Her conclusion was alarming.
The reddish sediment contained elevated levels of hexavalent chromium and several fluorinated compounds associated with industrial manufacturing.
Concentrations were far above those reported in Vale’s official study.
If Lily’s samples were accurate, groundwater near one of Halcyon’s facilities may have been contaminated for years.
Communities downstream relied on private wells.
“This could affect thousands of people,” Dr. Shah said.
“Could Vale have made a mistake?” I asked.
“Not on this scale. Raw instrument readings appear to have been manually excluded.”
“Meaning altered.”
“Yes.”
Dr. Vale requested a private meeting through his attorney.
Detective Quinn objected, but Allison agreed under controlled conditions.
We met in a conference room at her Chicago office.
Vale looked exhausted.
“I did change the report,” he said.
I wanted to cross the table.
Allison stopped me with one look.
“Why?” she asked.
“Halcyon argued the contaminated samples were anomalies caused by improper collection.”
“Did you believe them?”
“At first.”
“And later?”
Vale stared at his hands.
“No.”
He admitted Martin Creed threatened to withdraw funding, terminate graduate positions and accuse Vale of misconduct if he published the raw results.
The university compliance office pressured him to accept Halcyon’s revised interpretation.
Vale signed.
Lily discovered discrepancies while organizing laboratory files.
She repeated several tests without permission.
The results confirmed contamination.
“She confronted me,” Vale said.
“What did you tell her?” I asked.
“That she didn’t understand the political reality.”
“You told a nineteen-year-old to help hide poisoned water.”
“I told her to let me manage it.”
“She refused.”
“Yes.”
Vale claimed he later decided to support Lily.
He arranged the 10:30 meeting through an anonymous number because he feared university monitoring.
“But you weren’t there,” Quinn said.
“I lost my nerve.”
“You lured her outside and abandoned her?”
“I sent Noah to tell her the meeting was canceled.”
Noah arrived and found Darren Pike waiting.
According to Vale, Pike had likely intercepted the plan through Martin Creed.
Vale denied ordering violence.
“Why was Lily’s phone in your house?” Quinn asked.
“I don’t know.”
“Who has access?”
“My wife, housekeeper, graduate assistants.”
“Noah?”
Vale looked up.
“He had a key from when he cared for our dog.”
The evidence pointed in circles.
Vale altered scientific results.
He arranged the meeting.
He failed to appear.
But he may not have ordered the attack.
Someone used him as a convenient target after the fact.
Allison asked about the letters VA.
Vale shook his head.
“I don’t know.”
Back at the hospital, Lily began communicating more quickly.
She typed:
VA = VAN
“You saw a van?” I asked.
YES.
“What kind?”
WHITE. NO LOGO.
“Did Pike come from it?”
YES.
“Who drove?”
Lily typed slowly.
WOMAN.
“Did you recognize her?”
YES.
She searched the tablet for a photograph.
Professor Celeste Monroe.
My chest tightened.
Monroe had provided evidence against Vale and Hollis.
She appeared frightened of Halcyon.
But Lily identified her as the driver.
Detective Quinn showed Lily several photographs in random order.
Lily selected Monroe again.
We called Monroe.
No answer.
Her prepaid number had been disconnected.
Police went to her home.
The front door was open.
Her children were staying with relatives.
Her husband had not seen her since morning.
Inside the garage, officers found traces of reddish soil and industrial cleaning chemicals.
A traffic camera showed Monroe driving a white cargo van the night of the attack.
At 10:18 p.m., she entered campus through a service gate.
At 11:07, she left.
Professor Monroe had lied to us.
The email she provided could still be genuine.
But she had not been merely a frightened bystander.
Her university office was searched.
Investigators found $90,000 in cash hidden inside a locked cabinet.
A financial review showed regular payments from a Halcyon consulting firm.
Monroe had been informing Martin Creed about departmental complaints for years.
Lily’s confidential conversation with her had never been confidential.
Monroe was the one who told Halcyon that Lily planned to report the altered data.
At 6:00 that evening, Monroe walked into a police station in Springfield with an attorney.
She admitted driving the van.
She denied knowing Pike would assault Lily.
According to Monroe, Creed ordered her to bring Pike onto campus so he could retrieve the copied research.
“I thought he would frighten her,” Monroe said.
“You thought an ex-convict hired as private security would politely request the documents?” Quinn asked.
“He said no one would be hurt.”
Monroe waited in the van while Pike confronted Lily.
Noah arrived unexpectedly.
He attempted to intervene.
Pike struck him, then attacked Lily.
Monroe heard the blows.
She did not leave the vehicle.
She did not call police.
When Pike returned carrying Lily’s phone and a flash drive, she drove him away.
“Why was Lily left unconscious?” I asked.
Monroe looked at the table.
“Pike said she was breathing.”
“You didn’t check.”
“No.”
“You drove away while my daughter’s face was broken in six places.”
“I was afraid.”
“So was she.”
Monroe began crying.
I felt no sympathy.
She then revealed that Pike gave Lily’s phone to Martin Creed.
Creed later placed it in Vale’s house to frame him.
“Who disabled the cameras?” Quinn asked.
“Grant Hollis.”
“Who planted the recorder in Lily’s hoodie?”
Monroe shook her head.
“I don’t know.”
Police moved to arrest Hollis and Creed.
Hollis was found in his office shredding documents.
Creed’s home was empty.
His private plane had departed hours earlier.
Destination unknown.
Darren Pike had also disappeared.
The attack was no longer an isolated crime.
It was a coordinated conspiracy involving a professor, a department chair, a security director and a corporate executive.
But one person still held the full story.
Noah Briggs.
At midnight, I received a text from an unknown number.
I tried to save her. I’m sorry I ran. They’ll kill me too.
A photograph followed.
Noah sat inside a bus terminal.
Behind him, a clock showed 11:58.
Then another message appeared.
May you like
Tell Lily I kept the copy.
---
