Chapter 4 - THE RENOVATION SIX YEARS EARLIER
Police found the contractor.
His name was Glenn Porter.
Sixty-eight.
Retired in Wisconsin.
Six years earlier, his company remodeled Richard’s pool.
He remembered the property immediately.
Not because of Richard.
Because of the wall.
During demolition, workers found an older concrete structure beneath the west deck.
Glenn wanted to open it.
Richard stopped him.
“Why?” Detective Ramirez asked.
Glenn’s answer changed the case.
“Mr. Cole said it was an old septic chamber and that his father had warned him never to disturb it.”
Richard knew.
Maybe not exactly what was inside.
But he knew there was something.
Then Glenn remembered another detail.
Richard brought in a different contractor for one day.
Not Glenn’s crew.
They poured concrete around the old structure.
Glenn objected because it interfered with drainage.
Richard paid him extra.
“Do you know the contractor?”
“No.”
But he had an invoice.
He kept old business records.
The invoice listed:
North Shore Structural Preservation LLC
I knew that name.
My chest tightened when Detective Ramirez showed it to me.
Colebridge had used the same company.
Dozens of times.
Demolition.
Site preparation.
Environmental remediation.
Total payments during my five years at Colebridge:
More than $9 million.
The company appeared legitimate.
But when I checked what I could remember from financial reviews, something bothered me.
North Shore often received “emergency” contracts without competitive bidding.
Richard personally approved several.
I could no longer access the system.
But I had lawfully saved quarterly audit packets from previous board meetings on my work laptop.
My attorney advised me not to search company information independently.
So I didn’t.
I told Detective Ramirez what I remembered.
She obtained records through appropriate channels.
That was how we discovered Howard Cole had used North Shore’s predecessor company too.
The relationship went back decades.
A family fixer disguised as a contractor.
Not automatically criminal.
But worth examining.
Then identification came back.
The remains beneath Richard’s pool were consistent with a young woman.
DNA comparison with Margaret confirmed it.
Eleanor Vale had finally been found.
Fifty years after she vanished.
Margaret did not cry when police told her.
At least not immediately.
She asked:
“Was she alone down there?”
Detective Ramirez hesitated.
“Yes.”
Margaret nodded.
Then:
“Now she isn’t.”
May you like
That broke me.
---
